Bill is not replaceable

Wow the comments here sounds like you’re all a bunch of antisocial nightmares to deal with in rL.

Comments don’t describe the code. They describe the decision to use this business logic.

If you stick to good engineering practices, like small methods/functions, decoupling, and having testable code, you don’t often need many comments to show what your code does. I always recommend a method signature, though, because you can save a few seconds by just saying that a block of code does, rather than me needing to read exactly how you turned one dict into another dict…

`//Get CustomerInfo from CustomerRepository by Customer ID or else throw an CustomerNotFoundException

public CustomerInfo getById(String customerId) {

return customerRepository.getById(customerId).orElseThrow(new CustomerNotFoundException());

}`

This is the kind of pointless comment I see in my codebase all the time. Best I can tell, a couple of my coworkers like to plan out their code using comments, then backfill in the actual executable code. That’s fine, but they leave the comments in when they add no value.

` public static LocalDate parseEndDateFromString(String dateString) {

    try {

        String[] split = dateString.split("-");

        //In order to get the last day of the desired month, we go to the first day of the next month, account for rollover, then subtract one day

        int month = Integer.parseInt(split[0]) == 12 ? 1 : Integer.parseInt(split[0]) + 1;

        return LocalDate.of(Integer.parseInt(split[1]), month, 1).minusDays(1);

    } catch (Exception e) {

        throw new RuntimeException("Invalid date format - must be MM-YYYY");

    }

}`

Stuff like this, otoh, is where comments are useful. The required format is obvious from the error message, the param and return from the method signature, the only part that requires a comment is the fiddly logic of accounting for the edge case where month == 12 and the rationale behind how we determine the last day of the month. As a rule, comments are for why something is being done, if it’s not obvious, and for magic numbers. Code should tell you what code does.

edit: can anyone spot the bug that I introduced with that parseEndDateFromString() method?