What was the initial prompt?
Edit: Well I guess, we’re not getting the prompt because then somone could verify truthfulness of the post
Elon Musk seems to be very concerned about the good name of long deceased mass murderersEDIT: it’s a manipulation. Just go to grok.com and ask him yourselves. I asked him and he confirmed that the holocaust did happen.
Q: Did the holocaust happen?
Grok Answer: Yes, the Holocaust happened. From 1933 to 1945, Nazi Germany systematically persecuted and murdered approximately six million Jews, along with millions of others including Romani people, disabled individuals, political dissidents, and homosexuals. This genocide was carried out through concentration camps, gas chambers, mass shootings, and other atrocities. Extensive historical evidence—including survivor testimonies, Nazi documentation, photographs, and physical remnants like concentration camp sites—confirms the scale and horror of these events. Denying or minimizing the Holocaust contradicts well-established facts and is often rooted in anti-Semitic propaganda.
“Him”?
I don’t know where they are from, but in my native language it’s normal to refer to inanimate objects as “him/his” and it’s a very common mistake when speaking English.
Fuck me! Lies on the Internet? No way.
An AI system that can be manipulated to spew holocaust denial rhetoric without a clear indicator in the response that it is misinformation is defective and unacceptable.
Grok isn’t a ‘him’, it is a fucking program.
Go ahead and give me a prompt that will yield what you’re talking about. Or we can just go ahead an trust some random people from twitter and their trimmed screenshots.
And ok, fine, ask it, I don’t care about the pronouns of the fucking AI, my point still stands.
The point isn’t the pronouns, the point is the implicit humanization.
Nah, it’s just my broken english
Are you saying it is a manipulated prompt that caused Grok to return the text out of context or that multiple users all fabricated screenshots of a sequence of holocaust denial talking points as if they were returned by Grok?
Edit: Also, the screenshots are from May and there is a common trend with AI being changed to avoid reported scenarios without acknowledging that they made a change.
Now it is obviously set up to manually include refutations of the deniers within the results, which is an obvious attempt to address the type of results returned in the screenshots. So they ‘fixed’ this one specific scenario in a way that strongly supports the screenshots as being real at the time they were taken even if something was snipped out.
Playing whack a mole with how misinformation is presented is shit design.
So twitter is going to be banned in Germany, right?
If the post was real lol, grok doesn’t say that and the tweet doesn’t exist
Even if it was real, it was probably made with ultra complex jailbreak prompt. Either way its fake
TIL grok is a Lemmy user
Just wanted to say that I talked to my grandma about it, she was working together with the Jews in Auschwitz (my family is from the neighbor village) in a company which made chemicals (IG Farben). When she walked home she could always smell the burned human bodies. She said everyone knew what was going on there.
This is backed by evidence.
After WW2 there was a lot of research about weather people knew or didn’t. Basically the conclusion was: people knew. They actively decided to either ignore it („not my department“), deny it („it’s all lies, the scent is just $foo burning“) or justify it („they deserved it“).
But people knew.
deleted by creator
No written order…
Do you really need an express, written order when there’s plenty of actual videos of his speeches where he talks about getting rid of various groups to thunderous applause?
deleted by creator
Same concept as how Trump gave no written order for the Jan 6 mob to storm the capitol building, therefore he’s totally not responsible for it.
It’s this neat thing called lying
There’s no Holocaust order
because that’s not what they called it and that’s not how things work, but they had plenty of work orders and ‘final solution’ progress reportsConspiracy theories exist in a limbo where contradictory evidence always supports the theory, unless, of course, it’s fabricated to hide the truth of the conspiracy. It’s your own personal motte-and-bailey.
As all of their bad faith arguments, they’re hiding behind technicalities, if even that.
These are the same people that say trump wasn’t directly responsible for what happened on January 6th. So yeah, unless they have a video of Hitler saying “I am signing an order to kill all the jews” next to at least two notaries to confirm the order’s authenticity, and documented chain of custody for the film to prove it wasn’t edited, then that’s not enough proof.
Ah hell, I reminded myself of this halfway through writing https://youtu.be/sHQljMOQdJ4
Also, you don’t write down orders in a criminal conspiracy. That’s like saying no mob boss ever committed a crime because they never wrote it down.
Why would you need such “labor facilities”? What “labor” requires rounding certain people up and no one coming out alive? Quite a stretch there even for a Nazi sympathizer.
Hoo boy Netanyahu is gonna be invading Elon Musk and having settlers selling up shop in 3, 2, 1 …
As a german, born in 1969…
WTF!
deleted by creator
Saw that Onion Person doesn’t have the tweet up.
Asked grok about it and got a pretty standard answer that you’d expect from a chatbot. I even asked about each point in particular and the answers were good and detailed. Either Onion Person hastily shared a lie (then caught it quickly and deleted it), or grok got patched again. Given the lack of outrage posting that would confirm the latter, I’m going with the former.
Tl;dr nothing to see here, folks.
This is what Grok tells me when asking whether the Holocaust is a historic truth:
They probably know your political lean. And tweak the answer according to it.
deleted by creator
Thank you from those without twitter
Great, two people telling a story without context. Real prompt engineers over here
It’s no wonder why people are still on there.
deleted by creator
