• 0 Posts
  • 23 Comments
Joined 17 days ago
cake
Cake day: September 24th, 2024

help-circle
















  • it’s called a thought experiment

    do i think anybody is realistically going to kidnap me and plumb my kidneys into a world famous violinist? no. but i can still use that hypothetical to make a point. do i think anybody is likely to run into a barn at 0.9c while holding a long ladder? no, but i can still use that to learn something.

    based on your response, i presume you agree that a group can do bad things, or even be on the whole bad by a very wide margin, but still do something good worthy of praise?




  • because it disrupts non-Israeli trade

    so, just to set a baseline here, are we agreed that

    • what israel is doing is bad
    • stopping israel from doing what they’re doing is good
    • stopping israeli trade might stop what they’re doing
    • therefore stopping israel from trading is good

    given that trade is definitionally between two separate parties, one of the countries in the equation has to not be israel

    how can you stop israel from trading without impacting other countries?

    tldr: the sanctions on russia also have an impact on global trade, so if this is your redline, you should be anti-sanctions

    I’m sorry that the words ‘attack’ and ‘war crime’ mean nothing to you.

    are you saying the blockade is different to sanctions because russia attacked ukraine and is committing war crimes?

    i’m not sure if you’ve paid attention to things in israel recently